Are We Educating Students or Just Moving Them Through the System?

“The object of education is to prepare the young to educate themselves throughout their lives.”

- Robert M. Hutchins

 
 

I spent 11 years as a classroom teacher, and more than 30 years ago I was already questioning whether our education system was preparing young people for the world they were about to enter. I wasn't questioning the importance of education. I had earned my degrees, taught in classrooms, and spent my career helping young people develop the abilities they needed to succeed. What concerned me was the difference between completing an education and being prepared to use it.

Thirty years later, the world has changed dramatically. Technology has transformed how we communicate, work, shop, learn, and conduct business. Entire occupations have changed, new ones have emerged, and others have disappeared. Yet much of our educational structure still follows the same familiar progression. Complete elementary school, move through middle school, graduate from high school, and hopefully continue on to college.

My question is simple. Are we preparing young people for the lives they're going to live, or are we preparing them to complete an obsolete educational process?

The Numbers Should Concern Every Parent

According to the 2024 National Assessment of Educational Progress, 40% of fourth graders scored below the Basic level in reading. By the time students reached their senior year of high school, 45% scored below Basic in mathematics and 32% scored below Basic in reading. These are national assessment standards, not direct measurements of whether every student is performing at grade level, but they reveal serious weaknesses in foundational academic skills.

The problems don't necessarily disappear when students enter college. In 2024, approximately 63% of high school graduates enrolled in college immediately after graduation. Among students who began college in 2019, only 61% had completed a degree or other credential within six years. Another 9% were still enrolled, while nearly 30% had left without completing.

Even graduation doesn't guarantee that education leads to the opportunities students expected. Research from the Strada Education Foundation and Burning Glass Institute found that 52% of graduates whose highest degree was a bachelor's were working in jobs that typically did not require a college degree one year after graduation.

These statistics describe different groups of students, so we shouldn't pretend they all represent one graduating class. But they raise an important question about the results we're getting from a system that occupies so much of our children's lives.

We spend enormous amounts of time and money educating young people. We should be willing to ask whether that investment is producing the preparation they need.

Stop Preparing Students for the Next Grade. Prepare Them for the Next Stage of Life.

For as long as I can remember, we've organized education around academic advancement. First grade prepares students for second grade, middle school prepares them for high school, and high school prepares them for college. The system has become very good at establishing what courses students must complete to advance.

But what happens when a student reaches the end of that progression? What if that student has never held a job, managed a budget, experienced a profession, or learned how to make a significant financial decision? What if the student has completed all the required courses but has no idea what kind of work interests them?

I believe we need to reverse the way we approach education. Instead of beginning with a list of courses students must complete, we should begin by asking what abilities they will need when they leave school. Then we should build an educational experience that develops those abilities.

That doesn't mean abandoning reading, writing, mathematics, science, or history. Those subjects are essential to developing an educated person. But they should be part of a larger purpose that includes learning how to function independently, evaluate opportunities, solve problems, and make responsible decisions.

Make Mastery More Important Than Advancement

During my coaching career, I never believed that simply completing practice meant an athlete was prepared to compete. The purpose of practice was to develop abilities that could be demonstrated at the start of the game. If an athlete couldn't execute a fundamental skill, moving him to a more complicated assignment didn't solve the problem.

Education should operate on the same principle. If a child is struggling with reading in elementary school, we need to identify the problem, provide additional instruction, and measure whether that instruction is working. Moving that student into more difficult material without addressing the weakness creates another problem for the next teacher to inherit.

I'm not suggesting we hold every struggling child back a grade. Students learn at different rates and respond to different teaching methods. What I'm suggesting is that we stop treating advancement as evidence of mastery and start providing the time, instruction, and support necessary to develop the fundamentals.

Reading, writing, mathematics, and critical thinking should be skills every student continues to strengthen throughout their education. They are too important to be treated as boxes that get checked along the way.

Teach Students How to Handle Their Own Lives

I would like to see every high school student complete a practical life education program before graduation. Not a collection of occasional lectures, but a serious curriculum built around responsibilities they will face as adults.

Start with money. Students should understand how credit cards work, how interest accumulates, how to establish credit, and how quickly debt can become a problem. They should learn to read a paycheck, prepare a budget, understand taxes, evaluate insurance, and recognize the actual cost of borrowing money.

Give them real examples. Have them compare financing a vehicle with buying one they can afford. Show them what happens when they make only minimum payments on a credit card. Let them work through a monthly budget using a realistic starting salary and the actual costs of rent, transportation, food, insurance, and utilities.

Then teach them the practical responsibilities of taking care of what they own. Students should understand basic vehicle maintenance, how to recognize common mechanical problems, and when professional assistance is necessary. They should learn basic home maintenance, how to use everyday tools safely, and how to evaluate the cost of repairing something versus replacing it.

Physical health deserves the same attention. I've spent more than 50 years in weight rooms, and I can tell you that understanding how to care for your body is knowledge you'll use long after you've forgotten what you studied for a final examination. Students should learn the fundamentals of exercise, nutrition, sleep, recovery, and the relationship between daily habits and long-term health.

These aren't subjects reserved for students who aren't going to college. Every student will face these responsibilities, regardless of the profession they eventually enter.

Let Students Experience Careers Before Choosing Them

We ask teenagers to make some of the most important decisions of their lives while giving them very little opportunity to experience what they're choosing.

A student decides to major in psychology without fully understanding the additional education and licensing required for many professional positions. Another chooses a business degree without ever spending time inside a business. Someone else pursues a profession because it sounds interesting, only to discover years later that the actual work is nothing like they imagined.

Why do we wait until students have invested years and thousands of dollars to let them discover whether they enjoy the work?

I would begin meaningful career exploration in middle school and expand it throughout high school. Students should visit workplaces, interview professionals, observe different occupations, and learn what those jobs actually require. By high school, they should have opportunities for internships, volunteering, job shadowing, and supervised work experiences.

I'm not talking about asking a student what they want to be when they grow up and having them write an essay about it. I'm talking about putting them in situations where they can experience the work, meet the people doing it, and begin to understand what success in that profession requires.

They may discover something they love. They may also discover something they thought they loved isn't for them. Both discoveries have value, particularly when they happen before a student makes a major educational or financial commitment.

Make Critical Thinking Something Students Actually Practice

One of my greatest concerns is whether we're giving students enough opportunities to think independently. Knowing information and knowing how to use information are two different abilities, and the second becomes increasingly important as technology makes the first easier to access.

We need classrooms where students are presented with problems that don't always have obvious answers. They should learn to examine evidence, question assumptions, consider alternatives, defend their reasoning, and change their conclusions when better information becomes available.

That includes controversial social and political issues. Education should help students understand competing arguments and develop the ability to evaluate them. It should not be measured by whether students adopt the personal opinions of the adults teaching them.

I don't care whether a student eventually votes Republican, Democrat, or Independent. That's a decision they should make for themselves. I care whether they have developed enough knowledge and judgment to recognize the difference between a fact and an opinion, evaluate what they're being told, and make decisions they can explain.

As a teacher and coach, I wanted young people who could think when I wasn't standing beside them. That's what preparation is supposed to accomplish.

Connect Academic Subjects to the World Students Will Enter

I'm not suggesting we eliminate literature, foreign languages, astronomy, psychology, or other academic subjects simply because they don't lead directly to employment. Education should expose students to ideas, history, science, and cultures beyond their immediate experience.

But we should be better at helping students understand how those subjects connect to their lives and possible futures. Psychology can lead to careers in counseling, research, business, education, and other fields, but students should understand the different qualifications those careers require. Astronomy can introduce students to mathematics, physics, engineering, and scientific research. Literature can develop communication, interpretation, and an understanding of human behavior.

The issue isn't whether a subject is interesting or worthwhile. It's whether students understand what they're learning, why it matters, and how it might connect to the decisions they'll eventually make.

We also need to stop treating a four-year college degree as the only respectable destination. Some students will pursue advanced degrees. Others will enter technical occupations, apprenticeships, military service, or business ownership. Our responsibility is to help them understand those opportunities and prepare for the one they choose.

Give Students More Responsibility Before They Graduate

Young people need opportunities to make decisions while they still have teachers, parents, and mentors available to guide them. We shouldn't wait until they're living independently to discover whether they can handle responsibility.

I'd like to see more students involved in projects where they must establish a budget, organize a team, meet deadlines, communicate with people outside their classroom, and produce a measurable result. Give them opportunities to work with local businesses, community organizations, and professionals who can evaluate their performance.

And when something goes wrong, don't immediately remove the responsibility. Help them understand what happened, what they could have done differently, and how to improve the next time.

In coaching, some of the most valuable lessons came when athletes had to recognize a problem and make an adjustment without waiting for someone on the sideline to tell them what to do. The goal was to develop players who understood the game well enough to respond to what was happening in front of them.

We should want the same thing from our students when they enter adulthood.

Change What We Measure

If we're serious about improving education, we need to examine more than test scores, graduation rates, and college acceptance letters. Those numbers matter, but they don't tell the whole story.

Schools should also examine whether students are mastering essential skills, gaining meaningful work experience, understanding career options, and successfully making the transition into further education or employment. Colleges should provide clearer information about program costs, completion rates, required professional credentials, and employment outcomes.

Employers need to participate as well. If businesses want better-prepared employees, they should help schools understand the abilities they're looking for and provide opportunities for students to experience the work. Education and employment shouldn't operate as two separate worlds that students are expected to connect on their own.

Most importantly, we need to listen to the young people who have already completed the process. What did they learn that helped them? What did they wish someone had taught them? What decisions would they have made differently if they'd had more information and experience?

Those answers should influence what we teach the next generation.

CoachC Insight

I spent much of my professional life preparing people to perform. Whether I was standing in a classroom, a weight room, or on a football field, I understood that preparation had to have a purpose. The goal wasn't to keep people busy. It was to develop abilities they could use when the responsibility became theirs.

I believe education needs to be retooled around that same principle. We should preserve the knowledge and intellectual development that make education valuable while doing a much better job of preparing young people for the financial, professional, physical, and personal responsibilities they'll face.

The world has changed too much for us to assume that completing the same traditional progression is enough. We owe young people more than a diploma and congratulations. We owe them an education that gives them a realistic opportunity to build the lives they want.

Teachable Reminders

  • Completing a course doesn't necessarily mean mastering the material.

  • Preparing students for college is not the same as preparing them for life.

  • Experience can help young people discover both what they want to do and what they don't.

  • Critical thinking develops when people practice making decisions, not simply memorizing answers.

  • Financial responsibility, personal health, and practical problem-solving belong in every student's education.

  • The success of education should be measured partly by what students can do after they leave school.

Application Questions

·       If you could redesign high school education today, which practical abilities would every student be required to demonstrate before graduating?

·       How much meaningful experience should students have in a profession before committing years of education and money to pursuing it?

·       Are our schools measuring what students have learned, or primarily measuring whether they've completed the required coursework?

·       What responsibilities should schools, parents, employers, and students share in preparing young people for independent adulthood?

·       If we judged education by how well students handled life after graduation, what would we change first?


Next
Next

You Can't Change the Culture Without Changing the Messengers